August 26, 2026 · 5 min read
Red Flags to Watch for in Online Dating Over 40
By The Between Us Dating Team

Getting back into dating after 40 takes courage. Whether you're coming out of a long marriage, navigating life after loss, or simply deciding it's time to open your heart again, the vulnerability it takes to put yourself out there is real. And it deserves to be protected.
Online dating has made it easier than ever to meet people outside your immediate circle. But it's also created new opportunities for people who don't have good intentions. The good news: the red flags are almost always there early. You just need to know what to look for.
This guide will walk you through the 8 most common red flags in online dating for adults over 40, and exactly what to do when you spot them. Not to make you paranoid, but to make you confident.
The 8 Red Flags to Know
Here are the warning signs worth paying attention to, and the practical steps to take when you see them.
Red Flag #1: They refuse to video chat
In 2026, there is no good reason for someone to refuse a video call after a few days of messaging. If they always have an excuse, their camera is broken, they're traveling, they're shy, this is one of the most reliable warning signs of a fake profile or romance scam. Legitimate people who are genuinely interested in you will want to see your face. And you deserve to see theirs.
What to do instead
Suggest a short 10-minute video call early. Frame it positively: "I'd love to put a face to the conversation, how about a quick video chat this week?" A genuine person will say yes.
Red Flag #2: They move very fast emotionally
If someone is telling you they've never felt this way before, calling you their soulmate, or talking about your future together within the first week, slow down. This tactic is called "love bombing" and it's a classic manipulation strategy. Real connection builds gradually. Someone who genuinely cares about you will respect the pace of a natural relationship, not rush you into emotional intimacy before trust has been earned.
What to do instead
Trust your gut when something feels too intense too fast. It's okay to say "I really enjoy talking with you and I want to take this at a comfortable pace." Someone with good intentions will respect that.
Red Flag #3: Their story keeps changing
Pay attention to the details. If they told you they have two kids last week and mentioned three this week, or their job, city, or background keeps shifting, that's not forgetfulness. That's someone managing multiple stories or outright fabricating a persona.
What to do instead
Keep light mental notes of key details early on. If inconsistencies appear, it's completely appropriate to ask a clarifying question. How they respond tells you everything.
Red Flag #4: They ask for money, in any form
This is the clearest line. No matter how compelling the story, a medical emergency, a stranded situation abroad, a business deal that just needs a small bridge loan, never send money to someone you haven't met in person. Ever. Romance scams cost Americans over $1.3 billion annually, and adults over 60 are the most targeted group. The stories are sophisticated and emotionally manipulative. The safest rule: if they're asking for money, stop all contact immediately.
What to do instead
Report the profile to the dating platform immediately. You can also report romance scams to the FTC at reportfraud.ftc.gov. You are not embarrassed, you are protecting the next person.
Red Flag #5: They have no verifiable online presence
A real person in 2026 has some kind of digital footprint, a LinkedIn profile, a Facebook page, photos that appear in other contexts. If you search their name and photo and find nothing, or if their social media was created very recently with few connections, that's worth investigating.
What to do instead
Do a reverse image search of their profile photo at images.google.com. If the same photo appears under a different name or in stock photo libraries, that's a fake profile. A verified member badge from a platform like Between Us Dating is also a reliable trust signal.
Red Flag #6: They avoid meeting in person, indefinitely
There's always a reason they can't meet. They live a few hours away. Work is crazy right now. They're dealing with a family situation. These things happen once or twice in real relationships. But if weeks pass and every attempt to arrange a meeting is deflected, you're likely being strung along.
What to do instead
Set a gentle but firm timeline in your own mind. If you haven't met someone in person within 4–6 weeks of consistent conversation, it's reasonable to say: "I really enjoy our conversations and I'd love to meet in person. Is that something you're open to soon?"
Red Flag #7: They're disrespectful about your boundaries
You said you're not ready to share your phone number. You mentioned you prefer not to discuss finances. You asked to slow things down. And they pushed back, got defensive, or simply ignored you and kept going. How someone responds to your boundaries in the early stages of dating tells you exactly how they'll respond to them in a relationship. Respect for your limits isn't optional, it's the baseline.
What to do instead
You never owe anyone an explanation for a boundary. "I'm not comfortable with that" is a complete sentence. If they can't accept it gracefully, that's your answer.
Red Flag #8: Something just feels off
This one doesn't come with a checklist. It's that quiet feeling that something isn't adding up, even if you can't quite name it. The conversation feels scripted. The responses come at strange hours. The emotional intensity doesn't match the actual time you've spent talking. At 40+, you've lived enough life to have developed real instincts. Trust them. You don't need a reason to slow down or step back. Your comfort and safety are reason enough.
What to do instead
Share your concerns with a trusted friend before dismissing them. Sometimes an outside perspective clarifies what our hopeful heart wants to overlook.
A Note on Healthy Skepticism vs. Cynicism
Reading a list like this can feel discouraging. We want to be clear: the vast majority of people on dating platforms are genuine, hopeful, and looking for exactly what you are. Red flags are not the norm, they're the exception. The goal isn't to approach every conversation with suspicion. It's to stay grounded in yourself, to move at a pace that feels right, to trust your instincts, and to remember that protecting your heart is an act of self-respect, not fear. The right person will never make you feel like protecting yourself is an obstacle. They'll welcome your thoughtfulness, match your pace, and earn your trust, one honest conversation at a time.
How Between Us Dating Helps Keep You Safe
At Between Us Dating, safety isn't a feature, it's the foundation. Here's what we do to protect every member:
Photo verification
Every member completes a real-time selfie check before they can message anyone.
AI scam detection
Our system monitors conversations for romance scam patterns and flags suspicious activity automatically.
Optional background checks
Members can add a verified background check badge to their profile for an extra layer of trust.
Easy block & report
One tap to block or report anyone, with fast moderation response.
Number-free video dates
Meet face to face without ever sharing your phone number.
We built these protections specifically for adults 40+, because you deserve a platform that takes your safety as seriously as you do.
Ready to date with confidence?
Between Us Dating is a conversation-first, values-based dating app built exclusively for adults 40 and older. Every member is verified. Every match is meaningful. And a warm community of people who truly understand this chapter of life is waiting for you. Join free today at betweenusdating.com, no credit card needed.
Share this article
If this helped you, share it with a friend who is navigating online dating. The more we talk openly about red flags, the safer and more confident our whole community becomes.
Ready to meet someone meaningful?
Join Between Us Dating, built exclusively for adults 40+.
Get Started, It's Free